The Comet

As a self-respecting guy, I never had any use for a movie entitled Pollyanna, especially a Pollyanna released as a live-action feature by Disney. All I knew of Disney live action was what I’d experienced as a kid in the 1960s; you know, computers wearing tennis shoes, slime that made you jump high, and monkeys going home. Even as a kid I saw this wing of the Disney studio as producers of ridiculous, cornball stuff.

Now here I am well past my wonder years and I stumbled on Forever Young, the Hayley Mills memoir, and had my eyes opened to a pop culture phenomenon I knew nothing about since most of it happened before my time. Apparently, Hayley Mills hit the 1959 motion picture landscape like a tidal wave, first in the independent British feature Tiger Bay, which led to her personal introduction to Walt Disney and a starring role in Pollyanna, which was the brainchild of a 1950s TV director named David Swift, who managed to convince the big man of the validity of bringing the goody-two-shoes character Pollyanna to the screen.

My only real-time connection to Hayley Mills was when as a late-teenager she starred in The Trouble with Angels, which I remember sitting through as one of the first pictures I ever saw on the big screen. It wasn’t made by Disney but it felt like Disney, and Hayley Mills didn’t make much of an impression.

Thanks in part to a diary she kept and in part to her 2010s deep dive into Disney production files, Mills was able in her autobiography to reconstruct the experience of that first trip to Hollywood to make Pollyanna, and her backstage view prompted me to block out time and give Pollyanna a try. I sat down with slime and monkeys firmly in mind, and two hours and 14 minutes later, I was sobbing. Yes, my friends, I confess I was sobbing at live-action Disney.

The Disney studio surrounded Mills with veteran actors like Jane Wyman, Ed Platt, Adolphe Menjou, and Anne Seymour, seen here listening to a grim Karl Malden sermon about how “death comes unexpectedly!” (Others in the cast but not pictured here are Donald Crisp, Nancy Olson, and James Drury.)

Now I understand why this girl proved a global sensation hitting midway between Elvis and the Beatles. She describes herself in Forever Young as an untrained young actress who just liked to be on-camera and this captures the utterly natural screen presence of a 12-year-old Hayley Mills, who as orphaned Pollyanna arrives in a small, uptight town circa 1915 filled with bitter people to live with her strict Aunt Polly, played in veteran style by Jane Wyman.

The term “pollyanna” is defined by Merriam-Webster as “a person characterized by irrepressible optimism and a tendency to find good in everything,” and in as a person “excessively sweet-tempered and optimistic even in adversity.” The Mills/Disney Pollyanna is much more the former than the latter, an ingenuous yet canny observer of the human condition who barges her way into the lives of bitter recluses played by Agnes Moorehead and Adolphe Menjou and subtly brings them back from the brink of loneliness and despair to see the good in themselves and then in others.

Pollyanna meets and begins to influence a cranky friend played by Agnes Moorhead.

Pollyanna’s positive influence on the town around her grows so slowly over two hours of run time that we only realize the girl’s impact when she faces a health crisis and the previously embittered townspeople respond by charging en masse to Aunt Polly’s mansion to show their support and then, cue the waterworks (I teared up just writing this paragraph).

Pre-pubescent Hayley Mills was a revelation, with enormous blue eyes that threaten to leap off the screen to devour the viewer. Her eyes are almost science fiction, they’re so powerful. My reaction to Pollyanna made me seek out the feature that preceded it, Tiger Bay. Boy, what a contrast in plots, with young Horst Buchholtz in his breakthrough role as a good guy driven to kill his girlfriend as witnessed through the letter box slot by Hayley Mills and her sci-fi eyes. In Forever Young Mills describes her agonizing 12 year old’s crush on the 24-year-old Buchholtz, who would soon go on to make The Magnificent Seven. Their chemistry in Tiger Bay is purely compelling and overcomes any audience notions to question aspects of the noirish plot.

Crazy chemistry between Horst and Hayley in Tiger Bay.

Forever Young delves rather deeply into Mills family history, but then picks up steam when Hayley gets into acting—it’s clear that’s really when life began for this little girl. She takes you inside production of a 1950s indie feature and then suddenly we’re in Walt Disney’s office for meetings with the living legend and seeing blow by blow the back-and-forth negotiations between reluctant father John Mills and Disney lawyers who are on a mission to sign Hayley to a seven-picture contract.

I’m only halfway through the book but it’s already been something of a life-changer for me. For those not in the know, Hayley’s big sister is accomplished actor Juliet Mills, or “Bunchie” to those in the family while Hayley is “Bags.” On the set of Pollyanna Hayley meets actor Kevin Corcoran of the acting Corcoran clan, who is referred to in the book by his on-the-lot nickname of “Moochie.” I guess what I’m saying is the charm factor is high in Forever Young as we see stars of the screen and TV as regular people worth knowing.

So now you’re caught up on what’s been going on with me; I’ve seen Hayley’s comet for the first time and I’m getting up to speed on a talent who is proving, to me at least, quite capable of holding her own with Elvis and the Beatles.

The eyes that launched several Disney ships.


  1. Outstanding! You also reached me, a grumpy old veteran with what I call that quintessential aspect of a qualitative truth, albeit belatedly.

    It does seem we do have to revisit the arts which we saw or read when young and realize with new eyes, from the experience of life and a mature mindset those positive attributes we may have initially missed in our green years.

    Your blog has been a sheer delight and I don’t hazard saying I responded in the same understanding you so eloquently delivered in words.

  2. Remember the scene “DEATH COMES UNEXPECTEDLY!!” with chandeliers rattling? (roared by Carl Malden?) Key transformation.

    1. Yes!! Symbolic of dreary pre-Pollyanna life in town. After her effect on Preacher Malden, he gave up on fire and brimstone and smiled at his flock. I love this motion picture.

  3. Look up the “Moonspinners “. I loved the book as a young girl but seeing the movie right after was a disappointment, as most movies are when made from a book. I remember liking Hayley in this film. It takes place on a Greek island and in the book was a mystery. It has been some time since I have seen it. Another good one is “The Parent Trap” in which she plays twins.
    I am reading the book “The Boys” by Ron and Clint Howard. It is an excellent journey through childhood with wonderful parents and commentary on people whom he/they met and those that influenced them. I have only just begun (hmm a song I like too which was played at my wedding, but I digress) and am not even a fourth of the way through. I can’t wait to read more.
    However your cometary has picked my interest in returning to Hayley Mills’ movies.

    1. Julie, The Moonspinners is one that I watched a year or so ago thanks to Mary’s memories of seeing it first-run. Like you I was disappointed and found this to be much more in-line with the 1960s Disney vibe, which in this case is, contrived. I’ve heard others speak of “The Boys” and you’re motivating me to go read that after finishing the Hayley chronicles. It sounds like we’ve made an even trade.

  4. An intriguing account, to be sure – belatedly discovering the merits of an actress who perhaps was all-too-easily dismissed because of the saccharine fare that brought her fame in a handful of wholesome Disney films. Arguably more successful than older sister Juliet, who floundered in forgettable American TV appearances, Hayley resurfaced only fitfully throughout the 60s and 70s – sometimes making a splash through her stage work and in adult roles in select British movies…most notoriously, her marriage to the much-older film director Roy Boulting. Twice married and divorced, she appears to have found contentment in her personal life with a partner 20 years her junior, again echoing her sister Juliet. Still a potent and beloved “Disney Legend” maybe it’s time for a career reassessment, with some well-deserved honorifics to follow…?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s