I always understood the cult of Somewhere in Time without ever considering myself to be a part of it. I first saw this picture on its HBO release, probably in 1981, because of course no one saw it in theaters on wide release, where it bombed because Christopher Reeve’s star was already descending, and because an actors’ strike kept the two main players from hitting the road to talk up their new release.
Anyone who has ever loved and lost can relate to Somewhere in Time and the blackness, the despair of going on alone. There’s a desperation for happiness among the characters, a happiness so fragile every minute. I have to pause here and thank Matt of MattsRadShow on Youtube for his video that I stumbled upon stream of consciousness-like the other day, because Somewhere in Time was, right then, somewhere near the last thing in the entire world on my mind. I ‘got’ Matt instantly and wondered if we were twins separated at birth the way he and his wife, Ashley, traveled to Mackinac Island to track down and record key shooting locations—cleverly so!—and produce a video that I’d argue is as haunting as the picture it honors. [My aside to Ashley: I know you’re long-suffering because I have a better half who has similarly endured wild, improbable adventures in support of her man. Well played, my friend.]
So inspired by Matt’s work was I that I headed for OnDemand on a Saturday night and consumed this picture for the first time in decades. I loved it. Truly savored it. My reservations are still my reservations, but Somewhere in Time has three things going for it that simply overwhelm its drawbacks. The assets are, in no particular order, Jane Seymour, Mackinac Island locations, and John Barry’s score, which went through my head all night and is still there now. In fact, what the hell, let’s play it in the background while I write this.
Nice. Very nice.
Cutting to the chase, speaking just for me, Christopher Reeve almost ruined this picture. I was never a fan. I tried my best to like his Superman and succeeded for a while because the press kept telling me he was good. But OMG is he not good. He thought he was an actor but was simply too quirky, too unaware of how he was coming off, and proved it in picture after picture. Yes, he had his good moments here and there. But too many bad ones. I like to think if he had remained healthy, he would have gotten the right coach and really developed the talent that was inside him.
That said, I still remember exactly where I was when I heard the news he had suffered a catastrophic injury during an equestrian event. It shook me up; I never got over it. I’m still not over it. For a vital, successful young person to endure such a fate… The agony of Chris Reeve adds a layer of pathos to Matt’s video transposing Reeve at Mackinac locations with those locations today. It tears your heart out knowing what happened later on. I have to wonder if Reeve’s spirit doesn’t live on at Mackinac, so effective is Matt’s technique.
Somewhere in Time begins with young drama student Richard Collier being visited by an elderly lady who puts a pocket watch into his hands and pleads with him out of the blue, “Come back to me.” He stands there stunned, having never seen her before, and has no perspective on what’s happened. He goes on with his life and eight years later, as a successful playwright suffering writer’s block, gets out of his native Chicago and heads for a getaway on Mackinac Island, off the coast of Michigan. At plot point 1 he finds, and falls in love with, the portrait of a young actress on the wall at the majestic Grand Hotel. He learns her name, Elise McKenna, and that this photograph of such timeless quality was taken 68 years earlier, in 1912. Library research reveals “the last photograph taken of Elise McKenna” and it’s the old woman who had put the pocket watch into his hands eight years earlier!
OK, you’ve got me. A perfect first half hour of cinema. Now just don’t blow it. Reeve borders on being pretty good in this first half hour. He’s got all these fidgety, self-conscious mannerisms he thought people needed to see, but he largely keeps them in check during the set-up.
The way he gets back in time is preeeeeeeeeetty iffy. Not Reeve’s fault at all—it’s the device of the novel, Bid Time Return, by Richard Matheson. But eventually he does get back there and his meeting with young Elise on the beach by some trees is one of the sweetest, most effective scenes I’ve ever experienced. That location, that music, that woman, the intrigue of that moment and of his struggle to get to the bottom of the mystery but more importantly to get close to this face he’s fallen in love with. Reeve’s uncharacteristic, unbreathing stillness on the dolly approach helps the scene along as well.
Yadda yadda, they spend time together despite her pill of a manager (there has to be a bad guy) and it’s 45 minutes of standard romance with an obligatory sexual coupling before his iffy time-travel device comes a cropper, and he’s catapulted back into 1980 as she screams his name and witnesses his dematerialization.
I hated the ending 36 years ago and I hated it last night. It’s almost as if, “Welp, we’re outta money, folks, so let’s go home.” Red River comes to mind—90% of a winner of a picture with many touches of brilliance poisoned by an erring final plot twist. But as I murmured while experiencing the last 60 seconds of Somewhere in Time at 11:30 last night, James Cameron must have been one huge fan because he ripped it off down to single genomes for the ending of Titanic. I simply never put 2 and 2 together. Yikes.
Granted my misgivings, I’m urging you to set your disbelief on a shelf and spend 104 minutes on the journey of Elise and Richard. In fact, watch Matt’s rad video first and then consume Somewhere in Time. This world crumbling around us needs more romance, more lush scenery, and more pretty music. Somewhere in Time has all three, and my shout-out goes to Matt: Thanks dude for helping me re-find a lost treasure.
I love…absolute LOVE this picture. A good weeper is something one has to treasure, They simply do not know how to make a good one anymore. I guess ” the Notebook” was one of the last I remember that was so earnest in all its romantic glory that made you cry. Anyway, great to be reminded of this gem.
PS: Jane Seymour looks SO GOOD—look at her, this is 2015…she is in her sixties!
Jane Seymour is incredible in this. I was thinking watching it that just three years earlier she was some Arabian princess or other in the truly awful Sinbad & the Eye of the Tiger. It’s almost like this is a different actress. Yes! JS is an example of a vital human who remains in her prime. Thanks Priscila.
I love this post! I am not a fan of either of these actors, but once upon a time I loved this movie and was one of the few who saw it in the theater way back in my freshman year of college. I went with a friend who was madly in love with Christopher Reeve (or Clark Kent since she saw Superman several times) while I, on the other hand, probably agreed to see it for Christopher Plummer. I was such a romantic back then that this was the movie for me. I tried to watch it a few years ago and I couldn’t get through it precisely because of Mr. Reeve. Bravo to you for making it through and espousing its pluses which as you detail aren’t many. In fact, as I’m writing this I pulled the 1980 NY Times review and it is scathing. “‘Somewhere in Time,’ which does for time-travel what the Hindenburg did for dirigibles…” Harsh.
As for Mr. Reeve and Ms. Seymour, the only two things I’ve ever seen them in that I really liked were Deathtrap (him – he was perfectly cast) and the TV movie The Scarlet Pimpernel (her).
Thoroughly enjoyed this blog post over a cup of tea. Thanks!
Unduly harsh of the NYT, I think. I can only say in defense of this picture that I too have been involved in projects with some great things about them that just didn’t ring the bell for the audience. In this case I think the positives outweigh the rest; I cling to that. But I guess the true test is, I didn’t cry. Not in 1981 and not last night. It’s a fascinating and thought-provoking picture for me, that I can say, MGray. Thanks for reading this over tea!! And I do encourage people to see it and let me know the reaction.
It’s been a long time since I saw the movie, but I remember thinking – If he had only checked his clothes more carefully (I think it was a penny that returned him to his time) , he could have stayed with Jane Seymour. Bummer.
Your intriguing article about this movie inspired me to watch the You Tube video that you mentioned. That video has in turn inspired me to seek out this film and watch it. I am a fan of Jane Seymour and I admire Christopher Reeve, so it’s a bit shocking to admit that I’ve never seen this film. I’m sure I’ll enjoy it, especially because Mackinac Island has long been on my list of places to see.
I inspired someone! Thanks for letting me know, Bonnie. If you like these two, there’s a decent chance you will enjoy their journey through time. Please let me know how it turns out for you.